August 2012: David Goldblatt

Warren Siebrits & The Art of Collecting ™
David Goldblatt August 2012

A family and group of social outcasts, an author and intellectual and a church building are the themes that link a trio of vintage silver prints hand-printed by acclaimed South African photographer David Goldblatt (b 1930). These photographs form the focus of this month’s instalment of Warren Siebrits & the Art of Collecting. The three images are The Protea Grower and his Family on their Smallholding near Groot Drakenstein (1965), Stephen Leroux, during the day he farmed a huge estate, under the name Etienne Leroux he wrote highly acclaimed Afrikaans novels, one of which was banned (1965) and Zoar, Little Karoo, Cape Province, a house at a former Lutheran Mission Station established in the mid – 19th century (1968).
All three photographs form part of the seminal series of photographs by Goldblatt taken between 1962 and 1969, published some years later in book form as Some Afrikaners Photographed (Murray Crawford, Cape Town, 1975).
 
Collecting South African Photography Monographs


Some Afrikaners Photographed was a milestone in publishing in South Africa. Although the book was greeted with hostility by the Afrikaans community in particular, it is now regarded as one of the most important and collectable South African photography monographs, not only within the local context but also internationally.
To give an indication of this books collectability today, I have sold a pristine copy of this rare item for more than R 20,000.00.  Due to the misconceptions and closed-mindedness surrounding the publication of the book, on its initial release, it did not sell well at all. Originally priced at R 25.00, the edition was eventually remaindered for R 2.50 a copy. As the collecting maxim goes, if you want something to survive into the future make it expensive, so as a result at R 2.50 a copy not many excellent or pristine copies survive today.
 
Why Collect Photography?


If one thinks that finding a first edition of Some Afrikaners Photographed is difficult, try and find any of the vintage silver prints hand printed by the Goldblatt, which form the body of the book. These photographs are many times harder and more difficult to come by than more recently printed darkroom or digital images, which are most often not personally printed by the photographer.
The explanation is rather simple; at the time only very few darkroom prints of this series of photographs were ever printed by Goldblatt (which would by definition make them vintage prints), possibly due to the fact that it was an expensive and hugely time consuming task. It is this single factor that has made these early hand printed photographs so alluring and sought after by collectors today. Collecting photographs has everything to do with materiality imbedded in time. The same principle applies to book collecting; the first edition of a book can be worth a fortune whilst the second edition is often worth markedly less, irrespective of the fact that the two items are intrinsically the same. The varying pricing structures for collecting photography are no different. Early black and white images printed with Goldblatt’s permission in the last decade by Tony Meintjes in Cape Town do appear for sale from time to time, but these are not to be confused or compared with much older images hand-printed by the photographer himself. In collecting terms it is these vintage photographs, hand-printed by the photographer, that represent the first prize and are particularly sought after by institutional collectors (such as the Getty Foundation), leading international photographic museums and private collectors.
 
The Significance Of These Photographs


The Protea Grower and his Family (1965) is a photograph that illustrates the plight of the many outcasts of apartheid policy, in this instance a family whose racial purity was put into question by the state through the process of classification as either European or non-European.  In his essay titled The Anxiety of Identity in Some Afrikaners Revisited Ivor Powell discusses the significance of this image saying:

Similarly overlaid with political immanence is the photograph of the protea grower and his family on their smallholding near Groot Drakenstein in the Cape in 1965. Goldblatt notes in the caption that, at the time the picture was taken, the family were facing an uncertain future, fearing removal under the Group Areas Act. The observation is particularly pointed because, at first glance, one would probably not identify these subjects as ‘coloured’. Then, if you have been programmed or poisoned by living or growing up under apartheid, you look again – the texture of the mother’s hair, the unusual shape of her nose, the darkish complexion of the child. You also notice the way the woman holds back from the camera’s inquisitive gaze. It becomes uncomfortable…
(David Goldblatt – Some Afrikaners Revisited, Umuzi Books, Roggebaai, South Africa, 2007, pg 21)

Ironically, it was the Population Registration Act, which facilitated the implementation of the Group Areas Act, that led to the death of Dr H F Verwoerd, a year after this photograph was taken, on the afternoon of 6 September 1966 when Dimitri Tsafendas, court messenger, fatally stabbed the Prime Minister. Tsafendas was born to a Greek father and a ‘half-Negro’ mother in Lourenco Marques, Mozambique, and was teased from a young age due to his darker complexion. Although classified as white Tsafendas feared the ongoing possibility of reclassification from white to coloured. If reclassified he would have lost 50% of his earnings and would have had to suffer the social stigma of his downgrading. This was therefore one of the central motivations for him eliminating Verwoerd in the hope that South Africa would adopt a policy which would permit men of all races to marry freely and make one race.
Moving from the outcasts who were rejected by the apartheid system we come to an author and intellectual who opposed it. Stephen Leroux (1922-1989) is photographed by Goldblatt, standing cigarette in hand, on his 42 000 acre sheep farm in Koffiefontein. Leroux could well have remained an anonymous South African sheep farmer during his lifetime, but instead, under the name Etienne Leroux, he became one of the most important and influential Afrikaans writers of his generation. He was one of the founding members of the avant-garde literary group called Die Sestigers along with Andre P Brink, Jan Rabie, Adam Smal and Barto Smit.
Leroux came to national attention in 1962 with the publication of his novel Seven Days at the Silbersteins, which won the coveted Hertzog Prize – the highest Afrikaans literary award. Two years later the book became the centre of a furious, nation-wide controversy with members of the public calling the work ‘vulger’, ‘onheilig’, ‘pornografies’, ‘met ‘n verderflike volksvreemde invloed’, and ‘’n bespotting van die lewenswaardes van die Christen’, to name but a few of the accusations made in the newspapers and on radio back in the day.
As the writer gazes confidently and defiantly into the distance Goldblatt’s portrait of Stephen ‘Etienne’ Leroux imparts an air of sophistication, erudition and intellectual insight. One also senses the commonality and the obvious similarities shared by photographer and his subject, which may go some way in explaining Goldblatt’s decision in making Leroux’s acquaintance. Both men’s creative work evidences a very strong moral fibre, both used their respective artistic talents to confront and challenge dogma and closed-mindedness within South African society. Leroux’s portrait is also unique in its inclusion in Some Afrikaners Photographed, the only intellectual and celebrated figure who stands perpendicular to Goldblatt’s lens, at right angles and cross-grained so to speak, in his opposition to the status quo during the mid-sixties in white South Africa.
The third photograph titled Zoar, a house at a former Lutheran mission station, Little Karoo, Cape Province (1968) links these two disparate positions in society, namely that of the racial outcasts and the dissident writer. The church, the home of the bible and its teachings, became the moral justification for apartheid, a principle and ideology that based itself on the racial supremacy of the white Afrikaner in South Africa. The Calvinist principle and philosophy is represented by Goldblatt’s photograph of the 19th century mission station at Zoar, a physical structure which helped lay the supremacist and separatist foundation for apartheid more than a century earlier. Although the outcasts and the dissident writer have little in common, they are both ostracised. Whilst the church rejects the outcasts against their will due to their genetic ‘impurity’, the dissident writer and intellectual rejects the church and its teachings by choice, as a perverse and impure product of ideology and social engineering.
 
Conclusion


How did apartheid come into being, where was its rise and its zenith, and when did it begin to fall? These are the questions posed by these three deceptively simple, yet multi-faceted photographs. What makes these images astonishing and gives them their hallowed status amongst international academics and collectors is that David Goldblatt saw these paradigms without the luxury of hindsight, almost fifty years ago, when he created this remarkable body of work.
David Goldblatt’s approach to taking a photograph also provides an important insight to every true and innovative collector: do not be part of the herd and do everything in your power to develop your ability to see things early and in advance of the status quo

I didn’t take enough advantage of his proximity, didn’t see him as often as I might. David Goldblatt’s photography is a body of work which I hold especially dear…He never simplifies a moral statement, never sensationalises a situation. With rare exceptions, he does not record crises, whether of action, violence or suffering. Sensitised to meaning, he prefers to render quieter phases of existence…his work goes some way towards supplying a tradition of full consciousness that has been lacking in this country.
Lionel Abrahams, Johannesburg, 2004
 


Specially Bound Volumes Of Goldblatt’s Books For Sale


Four quarter leather hand-bound volumes, by Lunetta Bartz bound at the Peter Carstens Bindery, of Some Afrikaners Revisited will also be available for sale. Ten copies of the standard edition of the same title are also available for sale. This book has been out of print for some time.

David Goldblatt (Randfontein, South Africa, b 1930)
The Protea Grower and his Family on their Smallholding near Groot Drakenstein
vintage silverprint
25 x 16,5 cm
signed and dated
1965

David Goldblatt (Randfontein, South Africa, b 1930)
Stephen Leroux, during the day he farmed a huge estate, 
under the name Etienne Leroux he wrote highly acclaimed Afrikaans novels, one of which was banned
vintage silverprint
25 x 16,5 cm
signed and dated
1965

David Goldblatt (Randfontein, South Africa, b 1930)
Zoar, Little Karoo, Cape Province, a house at a former Lutheran Mission Station 
established in the mid – 19th century 
vintage silverprint
25 x 25 cm
signed and dated
1968

Back to blog